The Pizza Man of Kaua‘i: Pietro’s Pizza e Pasta in Poipu
By Kent Coules, Publisher
One of Tom Iannucci's mouth-watering concoctions, fresh from the oven
When most people think of “pizza” and “Hawai‘i” they think of pineapple and ham. Tom Iannucci thinks about brick ovens and learning more from his peers at the Association of Verace Pizza Napoletana, who commissioned his pizzeria as their first certified pizzeria in Hawai‘i.
It all started on Long Island, New York, where Tom grew up. “It wasn’t the best neighborhood,” says Tom. “A lot of my buddies were going to jail, so after the Beirut bombing in 1983, I joined the Marines. I met my wife, D’lissa, in Tokyo and meeting her changed my life.”
“I actually ended up stationed at the embassy in Beirut as part of the Marine Diplomatic Security Force. One day, when the phones actually worked I called D’lissa, who grew up on Kaua‘i and she asked me, ‘what’s it going to be? New York or Hawai‘i?’ At that point, Hawai‘i sounded really good.”
Iannucci’s first stay in Kaua‘i only lasted a month. “Coming from where I did, it was too quiet, too soon. So we moved to O‘ahu for four years before returning. When we did, I threw myself into the community. I became an Assistant Pastor for Calvary Chapel, visited prisons and spoke at many schools.”
But through this period, something was missing. Pizza.
“I couldn’t eat the pizza in Hawai‘i. Not on O‘ahu and not here on Kaua‘i. I drove my wife crazy making pizzas in our little apartment’s oven. I started calling pizza parlors in New York City asking for advice. Most weren’t very friendly, but I persisted. I installed a gas oven in my carport and began to host big pizza parties for the kids. People actually got offended, feeling slighted because they weren’t invited. Eventually, I built a brick oven in the driveway and started delivering the pizzas to the neighbors, and even making them for the police and fire stations.”
Tom with his patient and supportive wife, D'lissa
Iannucci traveled the world chasing his passion. On a trip to Naples, he fell in love with Neapolitan style pizza, a method that involves a pizza that is cooked in brick ovens at temperatures in excess of 900 degrees for as little as 90 seconds. “For my 50th birthday, my wife asked me what I wanted,” Iannucci remembers. “I said ‘I want to go to the International Pizza Expo in Las Vegas.’” It was there that Iannucci found his lost tribe. “They were all speaking my language!”
With the brick oven he built from scratch, he started making pizzas by the dozen. “People told me for years I needed to open a restaurant, but it wasn’t until I woke up one day with three kids in college, and trying to get by on a pastor’s salary that I actually decided to take the advice.”
With a little financial help from his friend and partner Dave Erickson, and after 32 years of assimilating to local culture, Iannucci opened the first Pietro’s in August 2015 on Rice Street in Lihue. Shortly after, the current front location became available, and that opened in May of 2016. “We sold out every day for two weeks,” says Iannucci, “We were so busy, I couldn’t even get the Neapolitan side open until August.”
Pietro’s has proven to be very popular and was even named “Editor’s Choice” for Best New Restaurant in the 2018 edition of Hawaii Magazine’s Best of the Best. With a new opening a the Poipu Shopping Village, Iannucci launched a new restaurant and lounge in April 2019 named Pietro’s Pizza e Pasta. “It’s four times larger than the original and will feature pasta as well as pizza. I imported a wood-fired oven from Naples and an electric oven from Rome.”
The new Pietro’s is also more diversified in that it features live music in the lounge. “The showcase will always be pizza,” says Iannucci, “but I want to work on sauces, new pizzas and specialty dishes. With Chef Dave Boucher as General Manager, they hope to create authentic pizza and Italian dishes.
As a former resident of the New York City area, I asked Iannucci about the legend of New York water making for the best pizza doughs. “There’s truth to that,” he says, “but Kaua‘i has some of the best water in the world. Our water comes as natural artesian water that filters down from Mount Wai‘ale‘ale, where it rains 540 inches per year. I’ll put our water up against anyone’s.”
Lastly, I had to ask Iannucci about his favorite pizza. “I’m a meat lover—Portuguese sausage, pepperoni chunks and add some jalapeno’s for a good kick. But our signature pizza is the pepperoni, aptly named The Don Pietro.”
For more information on Pietro’s go to pietroskauai.com.
[Editor's Note: A version of this article appears in print in the June-August 2019 issue of This Week Kauai.]
Keywords: pizza kauai italian food kauai italian dining kauai pizza poipu best pizza kauai best pizza poipu best italian kauai great pizza neapolitan pizza
Plan Your Trip
Book Your Vacation
Plan your own idyllic getaway with the Hawaii travel experts. Our partner, Pleasant Holidays, has created unforgettable vacations to the Hawaiian Islands for more than half a century, and can help you with all your travel arrangements.
Experience Your Hawaii
Enhance your vacation with activities and experience the very best of the islands. From helicopter flights to snorkeling adventures, from luaus to eco-tours, Pleasant Activities has hundreds of engaging activities that will catch your fancy.