Dive Into Maui’s Seafood Spots

Maui • April 1, 2020

When you’re vacationing in the middle of the Pacific, it’s only natural that you’d want to sample some of the ocean’s bounty. Fortunately for you, Maui has some great seafood spots offering dishes cooked in familiar styles or with a unique island vibe.

Fish Salad at Down the Hatch
Grilled Fish Salad at Down the Hatch

Seafood is made fun at Down the Hatch . This Lahaina eatery offers selections “Between the Buns and On Top of Tortillas,” plus appetizers, salads and “Big Plates” like macadamia nut-crusted ahi and cajun-grilled fresh catch.

Enjoy locally sourced fresh fish in entrees such as the Fish n’ Chips, Mahi Mahi Tacos or delicious Ahi dishes. Experience the flavors of the South with their Shrimp Po’ Boy. Chill out in the evenings with handcrafted cocktails and local beers during an extended daily Happy Hour.

Sauteed Fresh Market Fish at Mala Ocean Tavern
Sauteed Fresh Market Fish at Mala Ocean Tavern

If you’re looking for a restaurant that’s intimate and relaxed, you can’t go wrong with Mala Ocean Tavern in Lahaina. Mala’s serves tasty small plates and entrees with a healthy twist of organic, whole grains and no hydrogenated oils. All sandwiches come on a house-made flax chia seed bun. They have a full bar and an extensive wine list.

Mala’s  enticing oceanfront setting has it all—exceptional cuisine, delicious handcrafted cocktails, and an excellent wine selection chosen by their head sommelier.

Homemade Clam Chowder Bread Bowl at Captain Jack's Island Grill
Homemade Clam Chowder Bread Bowl at Captain Jack’s Island Grill

As Sean Corpuel’s culinary skills outgrew the burger-focused menu of his Cool Cat Cafe , he decided to venture out into newer waters, so to speak. Enter: Captain Jack’s Island Grill , right next to Cool Cat on Front Street. “We created the concept around different ports o’ call. Captain Jack’s serves some of my favorite foods from all over the world, foods that we tested on the menu at Cool Cat before opening.” Their menu offers up all sorts of goodies in the way of salads, appetizers and specialty entrees like their award-winning lilikoi hand beer-battered Captain Jack’s Fish-N-Chips.

Captain Jack’s is a great place to enjoy a casual meal or a cocktail as the sun goes down, a respite amidst all the action and a bird’s eye view of the famous Lahaina Banyan tree.

[A version of this article appeared in print in the pages of This Week Maui]

What Hawaiian Island Should You Visit? First-Timers Guide
By Cheryl Lee September 15, 2025
Planning your first Hawaii trip? Compare Oʻahu, Maui, Big Island & Kauaʻi in this guide to help you choose the best island for your perfect vacation.
By Cheryl Lee September 7, 2025
From farm-to-table fine dining and fresh island seafood to local shave ice and hidden roadside gems, Maui’s culinary scene offers something for every taste.
By Cheryl Lee September 7, 2025
From upscale boutiques to hidden local gems, Maui offers an unforgettable shopping experience that blends island charm with global flair.
By Cheryl Lee August 29, 2025
Whether you prefer sit-down with a view or a quick bite, we offer choices based on cuisine, ambiance and location.
By Cheryl Lee August 29, 2025
Get out and explore! All points of interest contain This Week Map coordinates and are free unless noted.
By Cheryl Lee August 29, 2025
Treat yourself and your loved ones with a special gift from the Big Island. Below are some local retailers offering unique island finds.
By Cheryl Lee August 29, 2025
Makalei Golf Clulb is an upland course in Kailua-Kona with staggering views and challenging holes-so much you'll forget your handicap and just relish the stunning scenery.
Hawaii’s diverse national parks, from volcanic craters and sacred coastal sites to historic landmark
By Cheryl Lee August 9, 2025
Plan your visit to Hawaii’s national parks with tips on history, best times, fees, and must-see attractions across the islands.
By Cheryl Lee July 18, 2025
Isle of windswept beaches, no traffic lights
By Cheryl Lee July 18, 2025
Residents of the Valley Isle say “Maui no ka oi,” meaning “Maui is the best!” It could be because of the long stretches of white sand beaches …or the idyllic offshore views of neighboring Lana‘i, Kaho‘olawe, Moloka‘i and the tiny islet of Molokini.